Natural capital in the South of Scotland
11 December 2024
One of our Board members, Grace Murray from Stow Community Trust, writes about the natural capital potential in the South of Scotland.
There can be little doubt that the South of Scotland is one of Scotland’s undiscovered areas for breathtaking scenic beauty, ancient history and warm, friendly folk. Many visitors who come to enjoy other areas of Scotland either fly over, take a fast train or drive through some of the most unspoilt parts of our beautiful country.
But there’s something much more that is being missed – the benefits of natural capital, particularly forestry across our area. Harnessing this resource can give us all sustainable growth, enhance biodiversity and contribute to climate resilience.
Forestry is one of the cornerstones of the South of Scotland’s rural economy. There are extensive woodland areas, including commercial plantations and native forests that have seen the region developing a thriving timber industry over the years. There are jobs to be had in forest management, timber processing, and supply chains. From sawmills to paper manufacturing, forestry can contribute significantly to local employment, offering opportunities across a range of skill levels.
However, forestry projects in the South of Scotland are often significant in terms of scale and impact on the local environment, as well as the potential revenue from timber sales. As such, the benefits of this industry need to be more widely shared, with communities taking part in meaningful engagement and securing tangible financial and non-financial benefits.
It’s not just about trees though, forestry underpins other sectors. Visitors are drawn to the scenic landscapes of the Borders and Dumfries and Galloway, where forests are intertwined with cultural and outdoor experiences. Activities like hiking, mountain biking, and wildlife spotting in managed woodlands bring visitors who enjoy our local arts and crafts businesses, accommodation, food and outdoor adventures.
The potential for expanding the bioeconomy is another key economic benefit of forestry. As demand for sustainable products grows globally, forestry in the South of Scotland is well-placed to contribute to green industries, supporting innovation and long-term economic resilience. This could particularly be the case if there were a greater diversity of forest owners, especially local communities, who could manage (and plant further) mixed productive woodland, and through doing so start to transition the South of Scotland to a forestry sector which moves beyond invasive conifer monocultures, to a mixed woodland ecosystem which delivers greater biodiversity and a variety of good quality hardwoods.
Forests are also vital ecosystems that deliver a range of environmental benefits. They act as carbon sinks, absorbing and storing carbon dioxide, which is critical in mitigating climate change. The South of Scotland’s forestry sector plays a key role in the UK’s carbon sequestration efforts, which should be used to help offset unavoidable emissions from other crucial sectors.
Forests also support biodiversity. Native woodlands, such as oak, Scots Pine and birch forests, provide habitats for various iconic species, from birds like crossbills and capercaillie to mammals such as pine martens and red squirrels.. There is no reason why such species could not be widespread around much of Scotland again. Sustainable forestry practices, including mixed productive woodlands, can balance timber production with habitat conservation, maintaining ecological integrity while meeting economic goals.
Forests also contribute to soil health and water management. Trees reduce soil erosion and enhance water quality by filtering pollutants and stabilizing riverbanks. In the South of Scotland, where agriculture is a significant land use, forestry provides natural solutions to challenges like soil degradation and water scarcity, ensuring the long-term viability of farming and woodland expansion.
Forestry enhances the quality of life for residents and visitors in the South of Scotland alike with accessible forests offering spaces for recreation and well-being, with physical activities in nature shown to reduce stress, improve mental health, and foster community connections. Facilities like Glentress Forest in the Tweed Valley demonstrate how well-managed woodlands can become hubs for outdoor enthusiasts.
Our forests are deeply tied to the identity of our region, inspiring local folklore, art, and traditions. Preservation of these landscapes sustains a sense of place and heritage, fostering pride and belonging among communities.
Despite its advantages, the forestry sector faces challenges, including balancing competing land uses, ensuring local communities are properly consulted and see tangible benefits from plantations, addressing climate change, and managing pests and diseases. Invasive species and climate shifts threaten both commercial plantations (which ironically are often comprised of invasive species) and native woodlands, requiring proactive management and innovation. Furthermore, there needs to be consistent use of Environmental Impact Assessments when forestry projects are established, to help assess the cumulative environmental impact of large swathes of commercial conifer planting across the South of Scotland.
However, these challenges also present opportunities. Expanding native woodland cover and adopting practices like agroforestry—where trees are integrated with farming and can create multifunctional landscapes that maximize benefits. Investment in research and training ensures that the forestry workforce remains skilled in sustainable practices, leveraging technology and science to optimize outcomes. If forestry corporations signed up to a community wealth building agenda and community benefit arrangements, the South of Scotland could start to ensure that jobs, supply lines and the profits from the forestry sector are kept as local as possible.
Collaboration is key to realizing these opportunities and the newly announced initiative, Natural Capital Innovation Zone (NCIZ) is a huge step forward in the South of Scotland that will maximise our vast natural capital assets. NCIZ will drive change and help address the twin crises of biodiversity loss and climate change through further developing our natural capital opportunities, attracting responsible investment and driving forward innovation and drive forward the wellbeing economy for Scotland, the UK and the rest of the world.
Information:
Grace Murray is on the Board of Community Land Scotland and is the Chair of Stow Community Trust
For further information contact our Policy Manager, Dr Josh Doble
- josh.doble@communitylandscotland.org.uk
- 07940 993 555