Assynt Foundation have been open about the challenges involved, and their experience offers useful lessons for others.
A key factor in progressing the work has been internal capacity at Board level. Developing agreements of this scale required detailed scrutiny of legal and commercial terms. In Assynt’s case, this was supported by having a board member with a legal background who could work through complex contracts and negotiations, and be a bridge between outside solicitors and the board. Without that level of expertise, it would have been significantly more difficult to reach agreement or to do so with confidence. This highlights the importance of access to specialist skills, whether internally or through trusted advisors.
Timescales have also been longer than expected. Developing partnerships, securing approvals and aligning funding took several years. This created pressure on the organisation’s finances and required interim solutions to maintain cash flow, including bringing forward carbon sales.
The Foundation’s experience with carbon markets also offers a note of caution. They have been able to generate early revenue through the sale of Pending Issuance Units, which has helped support delivery and bridge funding gaps. However, this has depended on timing, market conditions and access to buyers. It should not be assumed that similar projects will always be able to generate revenue in this way or at the point it is needed.
Community governance brings both strength and complexity. Democratic decision-making builds legitimacy but can slow progress and requires ongoing effort to manage expectations and maintain engagement over long timeframes.
Finally, persistence has been critical. Resilience, good leadership and a willingness to adapt have all played an important role in progressing what is a complex and long-term transition.